Monday, March 22, 2010

Review: The Heart is Not a Size by Beth Kephart


Georgia and Riley are best friends and they have been best friends all of their lives, but each girl is protecting their own secrets. They each have their own struggles they are facing and while Georgia is becoming more and more aware of what haunts Riley, she feels paralyzed to help her.

Georgia sees a notice of a group going to Juarez, Mexico and decides she wants to go and for Riley to go with her. The girls head off on this trip, but things don't go as smoothly as expected. Each girl will be forced to confront what ails them in this in a land much different than their own.

When I first realized this was going to be a book about Juarez, I expected a certain kind of read. But that's a mistake with Beth Kephart, who delivers only the most exceptional work and stories framed only as they are important to her characters. I didn't get a story that ripped my heart out hopelessly over a devastated area of the world, but rather a deeply human story that never reduced Juarez and the people who live there into something that can be fit inside a box. Kephart illustrates this beautifully when Georgia begins researching Juarez on the internet, she quickly comes to the conclusion it can't easily be put in a box. I can't tell you how much I appreciate this.

I loved the characters I was introduced to in this book. I felt for both Georgia and Riley. I understood the feeling of having a friendship that means so much on the rocks, and the hope to make a difference in the world. One of the things I love so much about Beth's books are the sympathetically drawn characters, never perfect but never condemned. Love without sentimentality. Romance whispering in the shadows. Hope that has its foundation deep within.

The Heart is Not a Size is about so many things, it's about friendship, it's about self-worth, it's about helping people, it's about the secrets we keep and the ones we shouldn't, it's about knowing who we are, it's about the healing nature of art.

Again, there's no poverty porn here. Just a beautiful story about some girls that go to a hurting area of the world and find healing where they might least expect it. It's beautifully written and achingly human. When I finished reading The Heart is Not a Size, I felt I had been treated to the very best of YA lit today, I felt moved, nostalgic, and hopeful.

Rating: 5/5
Source of Book: ARC received from publisher
Publisher: HarperTeen



Amy

Comments (12)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
With my deepest thanks (and my hand over my heart).
I just got this last week and did the happy dance when it came. I can't wait to read it!
Wonderful review! I love how you write that it is "achingly human." Those are the stories that reach the reader in the truest way.
She is such a talented writer; it sounds like she has written another wonderful book I will look forward to reading!
I just finished this one, and I really enjoyed it. Despite all the gushing, this book was the first one by Kephart I've read, but it won't be the last!
I can not wait to read The Heart is Not a Size! Thank you for the amazing review - I love that you tell me exactly what I want to know, without telling me too much. Thanks, Amy!
I didn't like this one as much as you did, but I'm not giving up on Beth Kephart. I've heard lots of great things about her.

"Poverty porn" - I've never heard that term before, but what a great way to describe how some authors describe impoverished areas.
Not that I'm surprised you loved it, but that's still good to hear. I'm getting someone's extra copy and can't wait to read it.
I had the same assumption going in when I heard it was about Juarez. So glad Beth Kephart surprised me, she's a talented author. My review of this one will go up mid-April.
What a beautiful review. And this sounds like a beautiful and deeply moving book. Thanks for sharing your thoughts on it. I will definitely be adding this to my TBR list.
You know I can't wait to read this! I love Beth's writing.
Just ordered this today and I can't wait for it to come!!

Post a new comment

Comments by

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to comment! I appreciate hearing your thoughts.