Tuesday, May 11, 2010

Review: Let the Great World Spin by Colum McCann

Let the Great World Spin
I know already that I will return to this day whenever I want to. I can bid it alive. Preserve it. There is a still point where the present, the now, winds around itself and nothing is tangled. The river is not where it begins or ends, but right in the middle point, anchored by what has happened and what is to arrive. You can close your eyes and there will be a light snow falling in New York, and seconds later you are sunning upon a rock in Zacapa, and seconds later still you are surfing through the Bronx on the strength of your own desire. There is no way to find a word to fit around this feeling. Words resist it. Words give it a pattern it does not own. Words put it in time. They freeze what cannot be stopped.

Reading Let the Great World Spin, it was not hard for me to see why it won the National Book Award. The structure and thematic elements are brilliantly done. I could feel the pulse and energy of New York as I read, the juxtaposition of the tight rope walker Phillipe Petit suspended above time, while the city beneath him seethed with the anguish and struggles of the everyday life of its citizens.

Let the Great World Spin is not the story of any one person, but it's the story of a city, of lives intersecting through time. It's told at times in first person, at times in third person. Sometimes it's the story of a Irish monk living in the middle of the city's most desperate citizens facing his own "wounded faith" his own struggle with God. Sometimes it's about the guilt of a bad decision, or the war mother who has lost her child forever. All the while, it's also the story of a city at one point in time.

This is not light reading, it's quite heavy and at times it felt like a fair bit of work to get through. There were moments of sheer beauty in the writing...not beauty in the lyrical way, but rather in the way truth reaches out and grabs you while you read, almost leaving you breathless. I certainly felt great affection for some of the characters and less interested in others, which I suppose, is the risk of a book like this.

This book is about time, about how events exist both wholly in and of themselves but also that they have a beginning and an end. Each moment in time has steps that lead there, and this is illustrated in the walk across the wire. And yet, at times, even though we each play characters in each other's stories, there are times we feel as lonely as a man on a wire above a world that is spinning.

Rating: 4.5/5
Things You Might Want to Know: Quite a bit of profanity, and some sex
Source of Book: Received from publisher for a tour with TLC Book Tours
Publisher: Random House

Amy

Comments (16)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I love your final paragraph. Between you and Sandy, I'm absolutely sold on this book.
Great review! I noticed on Twitter last night you mentioning that you were trying hard to finish it in time for the tour stop, so congratulations :) I'm definitely sold on the book as well and am looking forward to reading it.
I am so glad you enjoyed it! No, this isn't light reading at all, but something that can touch you deeply. For anyone reading this, if you are intimidated by the density of the prose or the length of the book, try the audio. It is a work of art, very simply.
Colum McCann is one of my very favorite writers, and while this is not my favorite McCann book there are, as you write wisely, some very beautiful, searing passages here. I am not sure the entire thing holds together. But I value it for its many extraordinarily thoughtful parts, and as a writer/reader/thinker, McCann has few peers.
The reviews I've read of this book are pretty varied, so I'm not quite sure what to think. I'm glad to see you liked it.
Fantastic review, Amy! I also really appreciated this book - wish I could post my review right now...but my tour date is the 28th!
I've been meaning to pick this up for ages. I find McCann books are a bit hit and miss with me. I enjoy some, but others are utterly meh, still this one has been getting great reviews, won loads of prizes, and is constantly checked out at work. All those people (and you) can't be wrong :)
I've added this one to my list.
I so want to read this book! It sounds fascinating to me and knowing it has your stamp of approval, I wish I had it to start right now! I love books that just sometimes grab you with the beauty and truth of them.
Your review is beautifully written! I have this on my to-read list - I'm hoping to get it from the library on audio.
Thanks for sharing your review. I really want to read this book and your recommendation is making me push this title up a few spaces on my TBR stack.
I've heard some really good things about this book, but it's nice to be warned that it's one I'll have to apply myself to and probably spend a bit more time on it.
An excellent (clear, well-written) review, Amy! I appreciate how you connected more with some characters than others. LET THE GREAT WORLD SPIN took a while to hook me, but I'm glad I stuck with it -- your review has captured the reason it worked.

This is the first McCann book I've read -- have you read others?
I am in the minority here -- you'll see my review next week.
I keep seeing positive reviews of this book and now yours.. I really need to read this book :)
Amy, I apologize for my long delay in commenting on your review. I'm reading this now for book club and find parts of it profoundly moving. Your review is excellent and really well balanced and analytical. Thanks so much for being on the tour.

Post a new comment

Comments by

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to comment! I appreciate hearing your thoughts.