I've been wanting to write some time about the lack of reliable and quality fiction review sources for Christians.
I believe there is a need for this, and while blogs can help, they are certainly only a small effort. Book blogs are fantastic, but they generally reflect a personal bloggers tastes and one person cannot cover all that's out there. For example, I love quality faith driven work, but I also have a great fondness for vampire literature, dystopian work, and other fiction.
While there are some great book review sources for Christians, they generally focus on nonfiction. And the fiction they review is general market, and trust me they review very little fiction. OR they focus exclusively on Christian fiction.
For someone like me, who believes there is quality Christian fiction, and issues of interest to believers in unexpected general market books, there are no satisfactory review outlets. The question is why?
I think many Christians still find fiction useless or a waste of time. They look down on Christian fiction as being lesser and when they cover fiction it's usually something that was written by an author who is known to have faith or a book that has already received acclaim in the general market. A perfect example of this is that Christianity Today awarded Anne Rice's Of Love and Evil the fiction book of the year award. No offense to Ms. Rice, but this was a clear sign that few actual fiction books had been read in consideration, 2010 was a rich year for faith based fiction.
I believe this is a huge disservice we are doing to the imaginations of believers. Fiction is a powerful tool, but there are too many books out there for the average reader to begin to know where to start. There are books that introduce complex ideas of faith and religion that will never be touched by Christian review sources because they come in the wrong packaging. And there are thought provoking and beautifully written Christian fiction books that will be dismissed as trash because of who they are published by. There is a real need for a review source that will find these books and share them with their audience.
The INSPYs were my first effort to work to bridge the gap. This post is my second. I would love to see more Christians take fiction seriously and I would love to see a really strong Christian review outlet take up this burden. Oh and if anyone wants to know...yeah I'm available for this job. :)
(writing this post today was inspired by the comments left on Mike Duran's very excellent post yesterday)
ETA:
I think from comments that people are misunderstanding what I'm saying here. I'm looking for this:
1) A review source written by Christians that reviews a wide array of BOTH general market and Christian fiction books...not just Christian fiction. :)
Friday, April 15, 2011
Faith and Fiction Saturday: We Need Better Review Outlets
Posted by Amy at 8:53 PM
Labels: Faith 'n Fiction Saturdays
Comments (27)

Sort by: Date Rating Last Activity
Loading comments...
Great post, Amy ~ as always :) The comments on Mike's blog certainly made for interesting reading!
I agree with you Amy, there needs to be a better and more rounded source of reviews for Christian fiction. In many Christian bookshops it is still hard to find a good range of fiction and I think people are afraid to try it out because of the cost commitment (it is rare to find Christian fiction reduced). I'd also be up for the job btw ;)
Hi, Amy -- Don't know if any of these will help, but I googled Christian Fiction Book Reviews, and got a bunch of good-looking sites...
Focus On Fiction, Christian Fiction Review, Christian Fiction Book Reviews (different from last one), Edgy Inspirational Romance (though, you probably already knew about this one), and LibraryJournal.com's reviews of Christian Fiction.
More to come in next comment... got too long, apparently...
Focus On Fiction, Christian Fiction Review, Christian Fiction Book Reviews (different from last one), Edgy Inspirational Romance (though, you probably already knew about this one), and LibraryJournal.com's reviews of Christian Fiction.
More to come in next comment... got too long, apparently...
(continued...)
...a GROUP/FORUM:
Edgy Christian Fiction Lovers (another you probably already know of)
And, lastly, Christian-Fiction.net (found on Squidoo --> someone said they had a hard time finding Christian fiction -- like you -- and then linked to this site, saying it's worthwhile)
Hope that helps!
~MizB
...a GROUP/FORUM:
Edgy Christian Fiction Lovers (another you probably already know of)
And, lastly, Christian-Fiction.net (found on Squidoo --> someone said they had a hard time finding Christian fiction -- like you -- and then linked to this site, saying it's worthwhile)
Hope that helps!
~MizB
Thanks for the mention, Amy. I learned so much from my commenters yesterday. Regarding Christian fiction review sites: The problems I've had is that they seem more out to "endorse" Christian fiction than actually "review" it. The result is lots of 4-5 star reviews, most without critical bite. 1-3 star reviews are seen as "unloving." It's a difficult divide because, on the one hand, the intention of a Christian review site IS to "endorse" quality Christian fiction. The downside is by not providing sharp public criticism we potentially contribute to an echo chamber and, its byproduct, more poorly written Christian fiction. Amy, thanks for all you're doing! Love your stuff!
Are you aware of CatholicFiction.net? It is a wonderful review site specializing in fiction with Catholic/Christian themes. I'm one of the reviewers there. Please have a look, you might find some good stuff that will surprise you.
Morning Amy! I don't have a lot of suggestions, but I ALWAYS love hearing your thoughts :) Happy Saturday!
They gave the award to Anne Rice for Of Love and Evil? Seriously?! I read Of Love and Evil and I can say that there have been much better CF titles published in the last year than that. MUCH better.
I think that Christian fiction has a long way to go in terms of quality (not that general market fiction doesn't), but I have seen progress. I admit though that I get frustrated with Christian publishers who focus on genre fiction--particularly the stereotypical historical romance genre. I think that if Christian publishers would try new things, experiment with literary fiction, maybe write about seemingly taboo topics like mental illness and homosexuality from a Christian perspective, we would see a greater respect for Christian fiction in general.
Recently I've been trying to read more Christian fiction, go a little beyond my comfort zone, and I'm happy to report that I've been pleasantly surprised. The first time I ever really took a stab at reading Christian fiction was about 2 years ago and I had a horrible experience. It was poorly written and pathetically sappy. Lately though I've stumbled across a number of gifted Christian authors who are writing at least a little bit closer to what I would consider literary fiction and they are changing my perspective on Christian fiction in general.
By the way, just a side note: One major figure in the Christian community who is a huge advocate for the relativeness and importance of Christian fiction is Randy Alcorn, who has written a number of novels himself.
I think that Christian fiction has a long way to go in terms of quality (not that general market fiction doesn't), but I have seen progress. I admit though that I get frustrated with Christian publishers who focus on genre fiction--particularly the stereotypical historical romance genre. I think that if Christian publishers would try new things, experiment with literary fiction, maybe write about seemingly taboo topics like mental illness and homosexuality from a Christian perspective, we would see a greater respect for Christian fiction in general.
Recently I've been trying to read more Christian fiction, go a little beyond my comfort zone, and I'm happy to report that I've been pleasantly surprised. The first time I ever really took a stab at reading Christian fiction was about 2 years ago and I had a horrible experience. It was poorly written and pathetically sappy. Lately though I've stumbled across a number of gifted Christian authors who are writing at least a little bit closer to what I would consider literary fiction and they are changing my perspective on Christian fiction in general.
By the way, just a side note: One major figure in the Christian community who is a huge advocate for the relativeness and importance of Christian fiction is Randy Alcorn, who has written a number of novels himself.
Maybe you aren't aware of Fiction Addict. The team of reviewers at FictionAddict.com reviews both general market fiction and faith based fiction. Since our inception we have been able to garner interviews with major authors in both arenas. Where else will you find an interview with Nicholas Sparks one week and Ted Dekker the next?
I too enjoyed judging for the first INSPY and hope it keeps on going.
I too enjoyed judging for the first INSPY and hope it keeps on going.
Just read your post. I agree that having delineation between Christian and Secular fiction is not always the best thing. Good writing is good writing and needs to be read and talked about.
I read both Christian and Secular fiction. Good stories are worth reading, not because of gratuitous trash talk and sex, but because of good story line.
A Review Site - covering both Christian and Secular works of fiction would be well received if it could be talked up enough to get readers, imo.
I read both Christian and Secular fiction. Good stories are worth reading, not because of gratuitous trash talk and sex, but because of good story line.
A Review Site - covering both Christian and Secular works of fiction would be well received if it could be talked up enough to get readers, imo.
Post a new comment
Comments by IntenseDebate
Faith and Fiction Saturday: We Need Better Review Outlets
2011-04-15T20:53:00-07:00
Amy
Faith 'n Fiction Saturdays|
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Post a Comment
Thank you for taking the time to comment! I appreciate hearing your thoughts.