Thursday, September 29, 2011

Faith and Fiction Round Table Discussion: Forbidden by Ted Dekker and Tosca Lee




I was supposed to post this last Saturday. And I host this discussion group. Lol I fail at book blogging this year.

Faith and Fiction Round Table is a group of bloggers who discuss books that deal with issues relating to the Christian faith...we've read a variety of books and this is our contemporary Christian fiction selection for the year.

To be honest, there aren't a lot of ideas/themes to pull from this book to discuss. Essentially, it's a sort of dystopian book where in the future the rulers of the world have managed to eradicate all emotions but fear. So imagine reading a book where the characters can't feel! Fun! It requires a lot of suspension of disbelief to make it through.

Despite all of that, I will say that I think our society has issues with dealing with emotions. And it's not exactly surprising, because they can be uncomfortable and not a lot of fun to deal with. Things hurt. Life sucks. So this book is pretty much saying, feelings are what make you alive...the ability to love and then feel the loss of love is what makes you human.

I remember reading this Russian vampire book last year where the vampire had a special gift of being able to feel what people around him felt. When he went to the theater, though, he could feel all this secondhand emotion. That really stuck with me, because I'm guilty of that I think. There are times when I have absolutely no idea there are broken bits inside of me and some ridiculous movie or TV show will open up the floodgates. And I think our society in general uses TV and movies to feel things in ways we refuse to feel them in our own lives and there's a kind of danger in becoming dependent on that. In living your life for the escape and outlet of stories about other people, instead of just, you know, paying attention to the story of our own lives. Of course there's a reason we have books, movies, and TV. It's only dangerous when those things become more real than reality.

And that's really all I have to say about this book. Others who posted:
Semicolon, Book Addiction, Wordlily, Ignorant Historian, Book Journey, Books and Movies, the 3rs Blog, Thomas Bingaman.

Amy

Comments (13)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I've always been perplexed that Dekker is considered a Christian fiction writer. I've only read one of his books, but it didn't feel very Christian to me! I know his parents were missionaries but still! I think you have managed to make some thoughtful comments from his latest. I may be somewhat guilty of experiencing emotions through books, or maybe books just unearth things that I'm trying to suppress!
1 reply · active 705 weeks ago
Yeah I think they do unearth emotions I try to suppress...which can be both good and bad.
I want to know more about this Russian vampire book! An empath/vampire? That's really intriguing to me right now. (Well, truthfully, all empaths are, specifically, this year.)
1 reply · active 705 weeks ago
"To be honest, there aren't a lot of ideas/themes to pull from this book to discuss." I pretty much agree - and having you say that too makes me feel better about not having much to say about it!
1 reply · active 705 weeks ago
Yeah it was a dud for discussion. And tbh I didn't really like the book.
www.itunes.com/app/thebookofproverbs

The Book of Proverbs for iPhone and iPad !
I know that this might sound weird, but I thought of Spock from Star Trek while reading the book.

The book did hit on a couple of things though. A state sponsored religion that teaches the only way to heaven is by being good and following the law. When people become sick, injured or deformed, they are killed off.

Thomas
1 reply · active 705 weeks ago
Yeah I just didn't feel like those themes were fleshed out enough i guess.
I'm with you, there wasn't a whole lot to discuss. I did find it really interesting the fear was the only emotion people could feel though. Reminded me of politicians and the media who use fear tactics to manipulate people... fear is powerful.

Hoping our next book is much better for discussion. :)
1 reply · active 705 weeks ago
I can't imagine only feeling fear. No wonder the were described as dead.

Here's hoping our final book leads to actual discussion!
Great thoughts Amy...I posted last Saturday too if you want to add my link..:)
1 reply · active 705 weeks ago
Hey Tina did you send me your link?

Post a new comment

Comments by

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to comment! I appreciate hearing your thoughts.