Thursday, December 8, 2011

Review: Bel Canto by Ann Patchett


So awhile back when I was but a wee book blogger, I read Dawn of She is Too Fond of Books review of Bel Canto and knew that I wanted to read it myself. I bought it at a Borders (RIP) one weekend and then it promptly sat on my bookshelf for years. I continued to read good review after good review and continued to not read it. This year I decided to finally read it, and sure enough I waited until December. (some books have been on my shelves longer just sayin. Bel Canto should feel lucky!) There was a lot of pressure involved though, okay? Raych said about this book, "Unless you are one of those who totally hated this book, in which case you may have no soul." Pressssssssure.

Okay so the premise of Bel Canto is that a special party is being held at the home of the Vice President in an unnamed South American country. It's being held in honor of a Mr. Hosokawa and to make it really special, they have invited his favorite opera singer. Opera is Mr. Hosokawa's reason for living essentially, so even though he has no plans to actually make whatever business deals he's there to make, he indulges in this exceptional party planned in his honor. The opening pages describe his love for opera and I have to admit they were completely breathtaking. I don't love opera in the same way, but I certainly love music and thought it was very moving.

So anyway they are at this party and the president was supposed to show up, but he doesn't want to miss his soap opera so instead he stays home. But the terrorists were counting on him being there and they don't realize he's not...and so they take the party hostage anyway. They feel like somehow they have to be able to strike negotiations with the country anyway. And they are assigned a negotiator, and so the story goes.

So basically what happens is you have all these people from different countries stuck together in the house and they can't all speak each other's language but there's one man there that's a translator of many languages. But more importantly, there's Roxane Coss who's an opera singer and when she sings, she is able to unite them in a way that only music can do. And it's beautiful. And during this time...four and a half months of stand-off with all these people stuck together in this house, they slowly start to build relationships of trust even with their captors. After all, a lot of them are young, teens, and you can find of feel the tragedy of their lives even if it's never explicit on the page. And since the terrorists aren't exactly cruel a lot of relationships spring up and the people bond. They fall in love, they feel deep affection for one another. They appreciate the wit, skills, and intelligence of each other. They even come to appreciate, in this sort of secluded life, different things they never had before, whether that be relationships or the time to spend on one's true passion and they often wonder, "how can I go back to life before?"

The beauty of Bel Canto is that you're reading along and you're realizing all of these things with them, you're watching them build a brand new kind of life together and destroy the sorts of walls between them and the whole time you're just feeling so much dread. You know that it can't last, that in fact there are terrorists and there are hostages and there's a whole outside world that is continuing on try to figure out this situation, and Patchett weaves that feeling of impending doom into the narrative masterfully and then suddenly the next thing I knew, I was sobbing.

I feel like Bel Canto is on the one hand, a love letter to opera or even more importantly the arts. It's through the early appreciation of the arts, one character tells Roxane Coss that he can now love her. It's the music that humanizes them all and breaks down walls. It's music that even after terrible things happen gives them hope in the world again.

"All of the love and the longing a body can contain was spun into not more than two and a half minutes of song, and when she came to the highest notes it seemed that all they had been given in their lives and all they had lost came together and made a weight that was almost impossible to bear."

I also think the music together with the exploration of time is interesting. It's only in forgetting time and imagining no past or future that many of the characters are able to enjoy the present. It's as if time has frozen for them and only in that freezing of time do the barriers come down and humanity prevails.

In a weird way, this reminded me a little bit of the film Joyeux Noel which I highly recommend! They are completely different in setting, etc. just the idea of people setting aside their differences and seeing each other's humanity are similar.

Anyway I loved the book, the writing is beautiful and the story is a heartrending and gorgeous tale.

Rating: 4.75/5
Things You Might want to Know: A very little language
Source of Book: Bought it
Publisher: Harper Perennial

Amy

Comments (34)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Beautiful review, Amy. This is one of those books I've known of for ages but had never actually considered reading for no particular reason I can think of. You've changed that now, though.
1 reply · active 696 weeks ago
I bought this book when our Borders was going out of business (a few years ago) based on all the reviews I'd read, and it's still sitting on my shelves. I'm glad to see you liked it so much.
1 reply · active 696 weeks ago
I know of the book, but I didn't know about the book. Thank you Amy for sharing your thoughts. Its not on my shelf...but I think it needs to me.
1 reply · active 696 weeks ago
I had a hard time getting into it, but once I'd read past the first few scenes, I was in love. It's on my keeper shelf. I want to read it again in different decades of my life, when I'll have different perspectives. Roxane and Mr. Hosokawa are unforgettable characters.
1 reply · active 696 weeks ago
I read this a few years ago, and LOVED it! It was such an incredibly beautiful and moving book, and now I want to read it again. I also just finished State of Wonder, by the same author over the weekend, and I must say, it was Fantastic! I loved it so much and am trying to get everyone to read it. It was such an unusual and interesting story, and Patchett really has a gift for creating these strange but totally believable situations. Great review today, Amy! I am so glad that you loved this book!
1 reply · active 696 weeks ago
I've seen this around and it's on the tbr, but you know, that thing grows and grows! Beautiful review indeed and I'll think of you and your review the next time I see it and pick it up :)
1 reply · active 696 weeks ago
I loved this one. I read it in 2007 and was just enchanted. I have the movie you mentioned at the top of my netflix queue right now! I read a book about that WWI event last year and have been looking forward to the film.
1 reply · active 696 weeks ago
A friend loaned this one to me years ago but I have never read it. Never returned it to her either. I need to read it!
1 reply · active 696 weeks ago
YES!! I'm so glad to hear this was love for you, Amy! I too thought this was such a beautiful novel and you explained so well what is so fantastic about it. Reading this review made me realize how much I miss your reviews! :) Selfishly, I hope you get back on the reading/review-writing train in the near future.
1 reply · active 696 weeks ago
Great review! I have this... One day I may even read it...
1 reply · active 696 weeks ago
It's official. I have no soul. I've tried to read this not once, but twice! I didn't get very far either time.
1 reply · active 696 weeks ago
I'm so glad that you loved this book!! It's one of my favorite books ever, and I think you reviewed it so well that I'm going to point everyone to your review.
1 reply · active 696 weeks ago
It's still sitting on my shelves too. I should make an effort to read in in 2012.
1 reply · active 696 weeks ago
I finally read (and loved) this book earlier this year after it languished on my shelves forever. I really want to read State of Wonder, I hope it doesn't take me forever to get to that one also
1 reply · active 696 weeks ago
I've had this on my to-read list forever - I really need to read this soon! Beautiful review, Amy. :)
1 reply · active 696 weeks ago
Oh no. It's been confirmed! I have no soul! I managed to read it all the way through but I have absolutely no idea what the fuss is all about!
1 reply · active 696 weeks ago
One of my favorite books!
1 reply · active 695 weeks ago

Post a new comment

Comments by

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to comment! I appreciate hearing your thoughts.