Wednesday, November 14, 2012

Review: Warm Bodies by Isaac Marion


So you all know that I enthusiastically embrace zombie stories and enjoy them. I'm always excited when I hear about new zombie books and I rarely feel like they are a disappointment. When this book came out a couple of years ago, people were raving about how great it was, so I bought it and gave it a shot. And...then I set it down unfinished. Well I'm trying to clear out my books so I'm trying to finish the books that I didn't quit reading out of pure hatred. And I knew the movie would be coming out and I wanted to finish it. So I did!

I didn't like it.

I like zombie stories where the zombies can't:
A) Think
B) Fall in Love
C) Turn human again

The reason I actually like zombie stories is because I like the stories about the humans struggling to survive. I like to think of the zombies as representative of something, but not human.

Warm Bodies is told from the POV of a zombie. But wait! On some level Marion knows that you need mindless zombies so there are zombies (flesh eaters) and bonies (no flesh, operate more like zombies) Sigh.

When zombies eat the brains they can see the flash of the life they are taking. One day R eats a brain and falls in love and saves a human girl...and well I think you can guess where this is going.

I just...no. No zombie awareness, please. No falling in love, no adopting families in zombie world or grunting talk with other zombies. That defeats the whole point of zombiesssssss. Also, no ridiculous theories on how the zombies were created, it takes all the subtlety out of zombie stories!

So I disliked the book. I do think it might make a cute fun comedy a la zombieland, though.

Rating: Ugh
Things You might Want to Know: This book contains faux-zombies
Source of Book: Bought It (in hardcover, weeps)
Publisher: Simon & Schuster

Amy

Comments (14)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I have a feeling I wouldn't like this one either. lol
1 reply · active 646 weeks ago
haha probably not :)
Sorry this one was such a disappointment! Hope the movie is more fun.
1 reply · active 646 weeks ago
I wasn't blown away by this book, but I was fairly entertained. I actually laughed a number of times...zombie humor and all that. (Which, by the way, I find Zombieland to be absolute genius in this category.) I found it curious that the book was intended to be a cast off of Romeo and Juliet.
1 reply · active 646 weeks ago
I guess I missed the comedy in the book, which is not surprising bc my sense of humor is lacking.
I really liked this one. I haven't read any other zombie books, but I do want to, and I think that starting here, and working my way into all the brain eating is going to gently immerse me into new things. I'm sorry you didn't like it, Amy, but I loved hearing a dissenting opinion.
1 reply · active 646 weeks ago
Aw yeah, I can see why people would like it I guess it's not just what I like in a zombie story!
LOL! I tried to read this one twice and failed. I am not a huge zombie story person so I didn't have the same issues you had, but I was just ... not interested in where the story was going, I guess, so I gave up. Oh well, you can't love them all.
1 reply · active 646 weeks ago
Yeah it was pretty predictable. I don't know why I didn't like it exactly, but alas it happens!
As one of the people that loved this book, I'm sorry you like it! I actually liked that it delved into the zombies' brains rather than the humans' - gave the normal moaning brainless beings personalities.
1 reply · active 646 weeks ago
aw, yeah I guess that makes sense. But my gosh if people are still present in zombie bodies all the killing of them seems even worse!
Someone Paul knows is raving about this book, says it's the best he's read all year, seems to think it's about resurrection (instead of apocalypse).
1 reply · active 646 weeks ago
Yeah I could see that interpretation one hundred percent. They talk about how the zombies started bc they were sick in the heart and the zombies do become human again. I guess that's just not what I read zombie books for!

Post a new comment

Comments by

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to comment! I appreciate hearing your thoughts.