Wednesday, January 23, 2013

The Silver Linings Playbook by Matthew Quick


Awhile back, probably around the time Sort of Like a Rock Star came out, I saw someone mention how great The Silver Linings Playbook was on Twitter and that they were looking forward to the movie. I then read a ton of interviews with Matthew Quick and became more interested in reading the book. But you know, like most readers I have so many books I want to read. I thought for sure I would get to it before the movie came out and I did not. Finally, with all of the Oscar buzz and so much stuff floating around the internet about it, I decided that I just had to read it and so I did! I had a few free hours one day and I breezed through it very quickly.

And it is a very lovely book, it is unique and quirky and delightful and goodhearted and pretty much a pure pleasure to read. I have not yet seen the film, but I can tell some changes have been made. I do not know how I will feel about them. Regardless, I'm super glad I read the book first.

It is adorable. And it's one of those books that manages to be comedic and light hearted without ever being false. After all, the main character of the book is mentally ill and learning how to cope in society again. That makes this book sound sooo much more serious than it is, though!

At it's heart, The Silver Linings Playbook is about how we might have an idealized version of what life should be like but that reality might not be so bad after all. Pat, the main character, is getting out of a mental hospital he's been in for the last few years. Pat doesn't actually think he's been there that long and it's only through living with his family again that he comes to understand what has actually taken place in his life and confronts the past and the reality of his future. Along the way he makes friends with Tiffany, a widow, and they do a variety of things together like go running and join a dance competition.

Pat believes there's always a silver lining to everything and he tries to keep a very positive outlook, which sometimes interferes with him actually accepting reality. Also, his family are huge Philadelphia Eagles fans and that plays a huge role in the story as well, in a way that I like because of how it gives a strong sense of place to the story, and creates interesting situations for Pat and his family and therapist. Also, through talking about football, Pat is able to talk about life which I love. One part in particular that I like, and the sort of tender sensibility this book has, is when everyone is very angry at Terrell Owens and it bothers Pat because of how people use his mental health as a reason to trash talk him. He says to his therapist, "If Terrell Owens is really depressed or mentally unstable, why do the people I love use it as an excuse to talk badly about him?" The book isn't preachy on this subject, but it does raise this issue in this way. (and obviously this also shows how empathetic Pat is) The therapist's reaction is disappointing from the standpoint that he doesn't seem to understand Pat's perspective on this--why it bothers him that people he cares do this, but it's also so real. The handling of this was superb in my opinion.

Pat's interactions with his family and friends make this book so much more than a romantic comedy. It's about Pat and his family and friends and yes there's a love story and a very nice one! but it's not really the central focus of the book.

Reading this book, it's very easy to see why someone would want to adapt it to film. First of all, like I said, it's delightful! It's a unique story and also there's even a whole section where Pat tells the story like it's a film montage. Also, he talks about how he's living the movie of his life and I don't know, it was just begging to be adapated! I hope it's good, because like I said the book was a pure joy to read and I'd hate to feel like justice wasn't done!

Rating: 4.5/5
Things You Might Want to know: Maybe a little language
Source of Book: Bought it
Publisher: FSG

Amy

Comments (20)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
"At it's heart, The Silver Linings Playbook is about how we might have an idealized version of what life should be like but that reality might not be so bad after all. "

Love the sound of this. And funnily enough I'd use these very same words to describe The 10PM Question, which is another book about people coping with mental illness and learning to adjust and live their lives on their own terms.
1 reply · active 636 weeks ago
aw that sounds like a good book, too, I think I saw you guys talking about it on Twitter the other day.
Oh, oh! Amy! Best movie ever! Katniss (LOL) is the best!
1 reply · active 636 weeks ago
I just saw this movie and I loved it. I was wondering about the book and it sounds like I need to read it.
1 reply · active 636 weeks ago
It's a great book, but I don't know how going to reading the book after seeing the movie will be!
What timing! I just put this book on hold at the library (still waiting for it to come in) after I saw a youtube clip of the trailer last week. I definitely want to read the book before seeing the movie, although the movie looks super cute!
1 reply · active 636 weeks ago
I know it really does! I hope you enjoy it :)
Sounds like such a sweet read!
1 reply · active 636 weeks ago
Thanks for this review! Ever since the movie made headlines, I've been curious about the book (because I haven't seen many reviews, honestly).
1 reply · active 636 weeks ago
I'll be curious to see what sort of changes they made but I do really love the book.
Have been wanting to see the movie SO bad ... now I may have to read the book first! :-)
1 reply · active 636 weeks ago
lol I know what you mean!
I'm so glad you loved this!! Makes the anticiaption of reading my copy that much more exciting! And, yes, I can't see the movie until I finish it.
1 reply · active 636 weeks ago
Yay! I"m glad other people will be reading it.
Beautiful movie...The characters are true-to-life, and you believe in every one of them. It's so enjoyable to see a movie that has real dialogue- a movie that isn't trying to be a drama or a comedy, but ends up being both! Oscars all around, BTW! For someone like myself who has personal experience with mental illness, the movie jumped from being moving to being memorable!
I saw the movie the other night and really liked it. The therapist was awful at his job but that's pretty typical for movie therapists, I feel like. The cast were all wonderful, and I laughed and cried and so forth, and I loved it that the movie didn't take a lot of the easy ways out that it could have taken. If that makes sense? Like it would have been easy to cast Pat's older brother as a sort of villain character, but that really isn't how he's portrayed overall. He's a flawed guy, just like Pat is. I thought it was wonderful and can't wait to read the book.
Your writing taste has surprised me, great reference. Thank you for this post.

Post a new comment

Comments by

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to comment! I appreciate hearing your thoughts.